Eyeliner

Here’s an updated, comprehensive overview of Pilgrim’s Eyeliner lineup—perfect if you're looking for long-wear liquid or metallic liners from their collection:

🎯 Pilgrim Eyeliner Options

1. Oh The Drama! Black Scandal (Liquid)

• Volume: 3.5 ml, rich matte jet-black with a fine brush tip for precision.

• Finish: Intense matte, waterproof, smudge‑proof, quick dry. Infused with Argan oil for smooth glide.

• Pros:

  • High pigmentation and black payoff.

  • Excellent long wear even in sweat/humidity.

  • Excellent for winged-liner and daily or dramatic use.

• Cons:

  • Single shade available.

  • Needs oil‑based remover to dissolve fully.

• Community Praise:

  “Very dark matte black…smooth to apply…stays 24 hours.”

2. Oh The Drama! Metallic Eyeliners (Liquid)

Available in shades like Boldly Bronze, Green Envy, and Blue Rebel (3.5 ml):

• Finish: High-shine metallic with water resistance and smudge-proof wear.

• Ratings (via Purplle): 4.3–5 stars for pigmentation, longevity, and smooth application.

• Pros:

  • Vivid color payoff and bold shimmer.

  • Smudge/water-resistant and travel-friendly.

  • Safe for sensitive eyes with precision tip.

• Cons:

  • Limited shade range and less common than Black Scandal.

  • No option for matte metallic looks.

• Popular Shades:

  “Green Envy — smudge proof and vibrant color…no redness.

✅ Quick Comparison Table

🧠 Community Sentiment

• Reddit users generally appreciate Black Scandal’s lasting power and ease of use, especially in hot climates.

• While Pilgrim’s skincare lines face some criticism, their makeup products, especially eyeliners, earn praise for consistency and value.

🎯 Best For You?

• Choose Black Scandal if you want a classic, long-wear, smudge-proof, everyday black liquid liner with fine precision and lasting intensity.

• Pick a Metallic shade (e.g., Bronze, Green) when you're aiming for bold, colorful eyes with long-wear and water resistance.

🧴 Tips to Maximize Use

1. Shake well before applying.

2. For Black Scandal, allow to dry fully before opening eyes to avoid transfer.

3. Use a warm oil-based remover (e.g. coconut or micellar oil) for easier take-off.

4. Metallic liners: Allow a few seconds to set after application for best smudge resistance.

5. Pair with Pilgrim’s eyeshadow palettes or mascara for a polished eye look.

Would you like help matching shades based on your eye color or outfit or comparing these to DUO- or Stila liners? I’d be glad to assist!